Herington City Lake (New) Fishing Report -
| Species | Rating | Size | Baits, Method & Location |
|---|---|---|---|
| Catfish | Fair | near wind blown flats and creeks on cut bait and worms | |
| Crappie | Fair | near points, brush, and rock 10ft deep on jigs and minnows | |
| Walleye | Fair | along the dam and edges of flats and points on jigs, worms, and spoons | |
| White Bass/Wipers | Slow/Fair | along creeks, dam and points on spinners, jigs, and crankbaits | |
| General Comments | |||
| This lake provides a diverse fishery, but best in 2025 should be crappie, wiper, and white bass. | |||